Rough Diamond is a feature written by the fantastic comedian/actor Steve E Blunder. It's the story of his father as he gets messed up in a diamond robbery gone wrong, the bad side of the law and the his family as he is accused of stealing the diamonds.
I received the first final draft of this script and began analysing it. Most of my corrections were cosmetic, touching up spelling and format errors but a few things stood out.
In this film, it's obvious that we are to sympathise with Steven, but we see the film through the eyes of his Father and the people involved in the robbery. Like the film Big Fish, it's a film where the main character, isn't the protagonist who undergoes the change.
My concerns with the story were that as it was written by Steven, he has a single idea on how each character was, what they did and why they did it. He's directly involved. He already had a bias which limited his capability to explore characters. They were real people so he skipped over the character aspect of the script.
I suggested that all the negativity about his Father, could be an outward projection of what he wants people to see him as. And it worked, as that's how Steve sees him. But I thought, there could be a more sincere side to him. People often to the wrong things to get what they want. I thought that his Father actually wanted to be a good father and loved Steve very much, just didn't know how to express it. Steve never thought of that because he had a single image of his Father his whole life.
Changing that, made his Father have a more humanised character and I think, made the script much better as it added depth and layers that some characters saw and some didn't.
Also, I felt that if Steve is the protagonist despite not seeing him much, we needed to see him on his adventures through childhood without a Father. There is a point where little Steve is playing with friends and goes against his Mothers wishes and plays in a dangerous place. I thought that this should be shown, as it would show us Steven on his own without guidance and show a little of who he is.
There is also an archive footage clip at the end which I didn't feel belonged there. I don't know if it's been taken out or not but I have been send version 2 of the script and will update this after I do my second script analysis.
Second version - The Rewrite
I received the second version from Steve and and we had a meeting about my thoughts. He has had a meeting with a rep from a major movie studio who said that once the script is finalised they would be interested in it. They wanted to have a main part as an American. Me and Steve were both on the same wavelength about making the villain and the corrupt cop Americans. We felt they were both fish out of water in the script so making them a different nationality made the most sense.
My suggestions:
I thought that the main villain wasn't too evil in contrast to our anti-hero who seemed an even match for him. I thought it would make more sense and work better for the drama to make the villain much worse than our anti-hero.
Another point I made was that we needed to see more of Bert and Steven when Steven was a young boy. For someone who makes a huge impact on the story, I thought he needed more screen time and we needed to see the significance he played.
I also felt that the corrupt cop who got punished by the villain, wasn't punished enough. In movie terms, he commits unspeakable crimes and needed absolutely severe punishment, the most in the film. Now, Steve is going to write in a much more fitting sentence for our corrupt scum-bag.
Finally, I felt the ending scene needed more screen time. It is a scene with the potential to be highly emotional and moving and was cut short because that's what actually happened. For the sake of the movie, I asked Steve to rewrite the scene and make it the most emotional damn scene he could write. I look forward to experiencing his rewrite very much.
I threw a couple of ideas to enhance what was already there for drama and tension, how he might go about writing a few things in. I don't want to spoil the movie ending or contents but based on our meeting, the rewrite is going to be absolutely incredible !!!
On the last note, the archive footage from the first script which I had issues with wasn't present this time. I don't know if it changed or what, but it fit this time. I didn't even notice it was there.
Second version - The Rewrite
I received the second version from Steve and and we had a meeting about my thoughts. He has had a meeting with a rep from a major movie studio who said that once the script is finalised they would be interested in it. They wanted to have a main part as an American. Me and Steve were both on the same wavelength about making the villain and the corrupt cop Americans. We felt they were both fish out of water in the script so making them a different nationality made the most sense.
My suggestions:
I thought that the main villain wasn't too evil in contrast to our anti-hero who seemed an even match for him. I thought it would make more sense and work better for the drama to make the villain much worse than our anti-hero.
Another point I made was that we needed to see more of Bert and Steven when Steven was a young boy. For someone who makes a huge impact on the story, I thought he needed more screen time and we needed to see the significance he played.
I also felt that the corrupt cop who got punished by the villain, wasn't punished enough. In movie terms, he commits unspeakable crimes and needed absolutely severe punishment, the most in the film. Now, Steve is going to write in a much more fitting sentence for our corrupt scum-bag.
Finally, I felt the ending scene needed more screen time. It is a scene with the potential to be highly emotional and moving and was cut short because that's what actually happened. For the sake of the movie, I asked Steve to rewrite the scene and make it the most emotional damn scene he could write. I look forward to experiencing his rewrite very much.
I threw a couple of ideas to enhance what was already there for drama and tension, how he might go about writing a few things in. I don't want to spoil the movie ending or contents but based on our meeting, the rewrite is going to be absolutely incredible !!!
On the last note, the archive footage from the first script which I had issues with wasn't present this time. I don't know if it changed or what, but it fit this time. I didn't even notice it was there.


